ePaper

Monday, April 23, 2018

Illuminating the darkness

  • Print

Divya A depicts some case studies from an era in independent India which illustrates what terrible woes can befall a nation when democracy is snuffed out, as unveiled by the author.

On June 25, 1975, a presidential proclamation declared a state of Emergency in India. Former Prasar Bharti chairman A Surya Prakash's latest book offers some case studies from an era in independent India which illustrates what terrible woes can befall a nation when democracy is snuffed out.

The book - comprising 14 chapters - builds on the premise that even as our basic freedoms were curtailed during the Emergency, its history is largely hidden from the younger generation. It looks at the arrests of political activists, media censorship, sterilisations, police atrocities and other such events that took place during the 21 months when Internal Emergency was in force.

Prakash has made it clear at the outset that his account is based on testimonies recorded in the Shah Commission (set up afterwards to look into the "excesses"), official records and his own experiences as a journalist (he was working with The Indian Express's Bangalore bureau at the time). In a chapter titled 'Ministry of Coercion', perhaps, the most scathing in the book, he comes down heavily on the high-handedness of the-then Information & Broadcasting Minister, VC Shukla.

Prakash talks of how even Kishore Kumar, one of India's most versatile musical icons, was coerced into singing pro-government jingles. In January 1976, the I&B Ministry decided to rope in film celebrities to do short films eulogising the Emergency.

It also wanted playback singers to sing jingles in praise of the government and its many schemes. When the I&B Ministry team heard from filmmaker GP Sippy that Kumar was not ready to be associated with the initiative in any manner, it was ordered that all his songs be banned for All India Radio and Doordarshan. Even the sale of gramophone records of his songs were to be frozen.

Shukla is said to have testified himself before the Shah Commission that "action was taken against Kishore Kumar because film artistes and producers had not responded to the government in the manner expected". The ministry's plan to teach Kumar a lesson worked as they soon received a letter of co-operation from him.

In the chapter titled 'The Drama in Prime Minister's House', Prakash elucidates the tense events of the day preceding the announcement. The then West Bengal chief minister Siddhartha Shankar Ray told the Shah Commission that the PM had told him that "India needed a shock treatment", referring to the situation in the country and an intelligence report on Jaiprakash Narayan's impending mass movement. Ray had later suggested to her that she could invoke Article 352 if she so desired.

Ray's deposition also offers insights into the relationship between the PM and her son Sanjay and the kind of grip the latter seemed to have had on her. According to Ray, it wasn't the PM's idea, but Sanjay's to cut electricity to newspaper offices and to order the closure of high courts.

The book also carries copies of some original documents pertaining to the Emergency, including Indira Gandhi's letter to the President on the night of June 25, 1975, the proclamation signed by President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, the minutes of the two Union Cabinet meetings held on June 26 in which it was approved and press censorship was clamped, and, finally, the presidential order signed by acting President BD Jatti, revoking the Emergency on March 21, 1977.


The reviewer is a journalist.The write-up has appeared on www.indianexpress.com

More News For this Category

Communal trauma and monstrosity

| By and Mahfuz Ul Hasib Chowdhury
Mahfuz Ul Hasib Chowdhury elucidates his views about an investigative text on the plight of religious minorities in BangladeshPainfully true that even after the independence of
Communal trauma and monstrosity

A journey of gleaming emotions

| By and Nafisa Faruque
Nafisa Faruque reviews some despairing days of 1971 with glimpses of precious hope allowingyou to experience everything through the writers' eyesThe year 1971 is etched as an indelible reminder
A journey of gleaming emotions

A saga of betrayal and colonial intrigues

| By
Mahfuz Ul Hasib Chowdhury scrutinizes a textual drive glancing back to the Battle of PlasseyThe Battle of Plassey (known as Palashi in Bengali) is one of
A saga of betrayal and colonial intrigues

A life beyond life: An appreciation of Chariot of Life

| By
Hayat Saif reviews the chronicle of an eye witness of the Liberation War of BangladeshTawfiq-e-Elahi Chowdhury's Chariot of Life, sub-titled Liberation War, Politics and Sojourn in
A life beyond life: An appreciation of Chariot of Life

The tide of nationalism for the rise of Bangladesh

| By and Shuva Das
Shuva Das illustrates the inner inception of independence movements ofBangladesh as unveiled by the authorProfessor A. F. Salahuddin Ahmed is an intellectual celebrity and a renowned
The tide of nationalism for the rise of Bangladesh

Scything the secular

| By and Seema Chishti
Seema Chishti depicts old fissures in the society of Uttar Pradesh that elucidated by the bookA clean sweep of Uttar Pradesh, with a tally of 73
Scything the secular

Call Me by Your Name

| By and Zarin Rafiuddin
Zarin Rafiuddin explores the multi-layered composition of love in this movie reviewEveryone's love story is distinct to themselves but what we can take from it is
Call Me by Your Name

A general's in-depth A to Z study of 1971 Bangladesh military operation

| By and Nadeem Qadir
Nadeem Qadir journeys with the author Major General Md. Sarwar Hossain, who gives a detailed study of his exhaustive research on how the Bengali army officers planned, fought
A general's in-depth A to Z study of 1971 Bangladesh military operation

Women have many beautiful aspects and not just appearances

| By and Zarin Rafiuddin
Zarin Rafiuddin reads the chronicles of Kaur's life through her poetryWhat does it mean to hurt, lose, love and heal? Such questions are asked and explored
Women have many beautiful aspects and not just appearances

The epitome of consciousness

| By and Mashiyath Rifa Ehsan
Mashiyath Rifa Ehsan unfolds the inner message of the movie.Padman, starring Akshay Kumar, features on raising awareness about women's menstruation and the superstitions surrounding the feminine

© 2018 The Asian Age