ePaper

Wednesday, June 20, 2018

Of a port city lost and almost found

  • Print

Amrita Shah comes across an incredible story how Surat lost maritime trade stature and an intrepid Nawab helped wrest back some dignity.


As India's principal port after Akbar's annexation of Gujarat in 1573, Surat was a critical node in the Indian Ocean trade circuit. The East India Company set up its first trading post here in 1608, followed by the Dutch and the French. A century and a half later, however, the fabled port city had declined.

The historian Ashin Das Gupta attributes Surat's eclipse in the eighteenth century to a simultaneous weakening of three empires in the oceanic region - the Mughals, the Safavids and the Ottomans. Other contributory factors included the silting of the Tapi River, recurrent raids by the Marathas and the machinations of the East India Company.

The last mentioned factor is the significant strand explored in Moin Mir's Surat: Fall of a Port, Rise of a Prince. Mir focuses exclusively on the East India Company's activities, marshalling evidence to show how the British wormed their way into a controlling position in Surat for the sole purpose of destroying the city to enable the rise of Bombay which they had acquired from the Portuguese in 1661. The Company took over Surat in 1800, signing a treaty with the local Nawab to pay a pension to him and his successors in perpetuity.

After the next Nawab died in 1842, however, the Company reneged on its promise, stopped the pension and seized the family's private estates. This was in keeping with the infamous 'doctrine of lapse' policy by which the Company gave itself the power to annex  a vassal state if the ruler was either "manifestly incompetent or died without a male heir". Thirty odd states would go on to be annexed under this policy.

Like their peers, the Surat Nawab's family made several representations to local Company officials but when they failed, the Nawab's son-in-law, Meer Jaffer Ali Khan, in an unusual move, decided to take the fight to London. The second half of the book describes this mission. In May 1844, Jaffer's delegation - his retinue included a linguist, a physician and a British personal secretary - landed up in England where Jaffer met the chairman of the East India Company and engaged in a hectic round of socialising.

His exotic looks, enhanced by resplendent robes and jewellery drew attention. Queen Victoria and Albert spotted him at Ascot and after listening to his case introduced him to a legal luminary, Richard Bethell. But the Company proved unresponsive and Jaffer's finances ran out, forcing him to return empty-handed to Surat.

In December 1853, Jaffer went back to London and, advised by Bethell and powerful lawyer-politicians, Erskine Perry and Fitzroy Kelly, decided to approach the Judicial Committee of Her Majesty's Council to sanction a Parliamentary intervention. Concern over the East India Company's doings had been rife since the trial of Warren Hastings half a century before, but it was still an immensely powerful corporation.

 The fight was tough - Kelly and Perry lobbied MPs to support the Nawab of Surat Treaty Bill. Jaffer  mobilised public opinion through pamphlets and the press. Eventually the House of Commons voted in Jaffer's favour and the East India Company was forced to make him a suitable offer.

It is an extraordinary story and Mir offers some fascinating sidelights as well, taking us through fashionable London haunts of the19th century such as the Royal Society of Arts, and letting us eavesdrop on Jaffer's staff. An amusing incident recounted in the book describes how a Christian missionary approaching Jaffer's numerous attendants with a view to proselytize, inadvertently turned the kitchen into a site of revelry instead.

 Mir, a scion of the Nawab family of Surat, is neither a professional historian nor a literary writer. His approach, which mixes research with a sentimental narrative style, often leaves the reader unpleasantly suspended between the real and the quasi-fictional. Nevertheless the book is an engaging read and sheds light on a neglected episode in India's eventful history.


The reviewer is a historian of Centre for Contemporary Studies, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore.
The write-up has appeared on
www.indianexpress.com

More News For this Category

Writings on the 1947 Partition

| By
Nausheen RahmanI have just finished reading "Footprints on Zero Line: Writings on the Partition", and I feel that my day was truly well-spent. This
Writings on the 1947 Partition

The game comes to life in this cinematic experience

| By and Zarin Rafiuddin
Tomb Raider (2018) is a reboot film to the franchise, which once starred Angelina Jolie as the titular character of Lara Croft.  Alicia Vikander is the new, younger
The game comes to life in this cinematic experience

Pops by Michael Chabon: A quiet look at fatherhood and writing

| By and Mark O\'Connell
Pops, the American novelist Michael Chabon's new collection of essays on parenthood and related matters, begins with an anecdote about attending a literary gathering at the beginning of
Pops by Michael Chabon: A quiet look at fatherhood and writing

A movie dealing with the failures and dreams of growing up

| By and Zarin Rafiuddin
Lady Bird (2017) is a different kind of coming-of-age story directed and written by Greta Gerwig. The eponymous Lady Bird, or Christine "Lady Bird" McPherson (Saoirse Ronan) is
A movie dealing with the failures and dreams of growing up

Last Stories by William Trevor: A final treat

| By
A few years ago, a friend gave me a two-volume, hardcover edition of William Trevor's The Collected Stories as a Christmas present. It's one of the most treasured
Last Stories by William Trevor: A final treat

Rampage movie adaptation is one fun movie

| By and Zarin Rafiuddin
Rampage (2018) is a movie where giant creatures clash at one another as they are endowed with rage and aggression. The movie stars as Dwayne Johnson (The Rock)

Why Ruth Ware's new thriller is a classic

| By and Maureen Corrigan
Why Ruth Ware's new thriller is a classicMaureen Corrigan A classic never goes out of style. Consider the confident simplicity of the dry martini, the Edison lightbulb and

Beyond the Breakwater by Catherine Foley: A humble memoir

| By
Pat McCabe has a lot to answer for. The class messer of Irish literature has altered forever how we read rural Irish memoirs. His evisceration of the central

Deadpool 2 full of graphic humor and adrenalin

| By and Zarin Rafiuddin
Deadpool 2 (2018) is the direct sequel to the Deadpool (2016), featuring the mutant Wade Wilson, also known as Deadpool (Ryan Reynolds). The movie was directed by David
Deadpool 2 full of graphic humor and adrenalin

Black Star Renegades is a loving homage to Star Wars

| By
Stop me if you've heard this one before. A young man discovers that he's destined for greater things in the galaxy, joins a mysterious, semi-religious order that act
Black Star Renegades is a loving homage to Star Wars

© 2018 The Asian Age