ePaper

Tuesday, January 23, 2018

Why is Japan populist-free?

  • Print

Even as a wave of right-wing populism is sweeping Europe, the United States, India, and parts of Southeast Asia, Japan has so far appeared to be immune. There are no Japanese demagogues, like Geert Wilders, Marine Le Pen, Donald Trump, Narendra Modi, or Rodrigo Duterte, who have exploited pent-up resentments against cultural or political elites.

Why?

Perhaps the closest Japan has come was the former mayor of Osaka, Toru Hashimoto, who first made his name as a television personality and then disgraced himself in recent years by commending the use of wartime sex slaves by the Imperial Japanese Army. His ultra-nationalist views and loathing of liberal media were a familiar version of right-wing populism. But he never managed to break into national politics.

Hashimoto now gives Prime Minister Shinzo Abe free advice on tightening national-security laws. And therein lies one explanation for the apparent lack of right-wing populism in Japan. No one could be more identified with the political elite than Abe, the grandson of a wartime cabinet minister and later prime minister, and son of a foreign minister. And yet, he shares right-wing populists' hostility to liberal academics, journalists, and intellectuals.

In some ways, Bannon was right to think so. In November 2016, Abe told Trump: "I've been successful in taming the Asahi Shimbun. I hope you will likewise be successful in taming The New York Times." Even as a joke between two supposedly democratic leaders, this was disgraceful.

So one might say that elements of right-wing populism are at the heart of the Japanese government, embodied by a scion of one of the country's most elite families. This paradox, however, is not the only explanation for the absence of a Japanese Le Pen, Modi, or Wilders.

For demagogues to be able to stir up popular resentments against foreigners, cosmopolitans, intellectuals, and liberals, there must be wide and obvious financial, cultural, and educational disparities. This was the case in Japan in the mid-1930s, when military hotheads staged a failed coup aimed at bankers, businessmen, and politicians who in their view were corrupting the Japanese polity.

The coup was supported by soldiers who had often grown up in poor rural areas. Their sisters sometimes had to be sold to big city brothels for their families to survive. The Westernized cosmopolitan urban elites were the enemy. And public opinion was largely on the side of the rebels.

Contemporary Japan may have its flaws, but it is now much more egalitarian than the US, India, or many countries in Europe. High taxes make it hard to pass on inherited wealth. And, unlike in the US, where material prosperity is flaunted, not least by Trump himself, the most affluent Japanese tend to be discreet. Japan has surpassed the US as a country of the middle class.

Resentment feeds off a sense of humiliation, a loss of pride. In a society where human worth is measured by individual success, symbolized by celebrity and money, it is easy to feel humiliated by a relative lack of it, of being just another face in the crowd.

In extreme cases, desperate individuals will assassinate a president or a rock star just to get into the news. Populists find support among those resentful faces in the crowd, people who feel that elites have betrayed them, by taking away their sense of pride in their class, their culture, or their race.

This has not happened in Japan yet. Culture may have something to do with it. Self-promotion, in the American style, is frowned upon. To be sure, Japan has a celebrity culture, driven by mass media. But self-worth is defined less by individual fame or wealth than by having a place in a collective enterprise, and doing the job one is assigned as well as one can.

People in department stores seem to take genuine pride in wrapping merchandise beautifully. Some jobs - think of those uniformed middle-aged men who smile and bow at customers entering a bank - appear to be entirely superfluous. It would be naive to assume that these tasks give huge satisfaction, but they offer people a sense of place, a role in society, however humble.

Meanwhile, the domestic Japanese economy remains one of the most protected and least globalized in the developed world. There are several reasons why Japanese governments have resisted the neoliberalism promoted in the West since the Reagan/Thatcher years: corporate interests, bureaucratic privileges, and pork-barrel politics of various kinds. But preserving pride in employment, at the cost of efficiency, is one of them. If this stifles individual enterprise, then so be it.

Thatcherism has probably made the British economy more efficient. But by crushing trade unions and other established institutions of working-class culture, governments have also taken away sources of pride for people who often do unpleasant jobs. Efficiency does not create a sense of community. Those who now feel adrift blame their predicament on elites who are better educated and sometimes more talented - and thus better able to thrive in a global economy.

One of the more ironic consequences is that many such people in the US have chosen as their president a narcissistic billionaire who brags about his wealth, personal success, and genius. Nothing like that is likely to happen in Japan. We might learn something valuable from reflecting on the reasons why.


The writer is the Editor of The New York Review of Books

---Ian Buruma

More News For this Category

Good governance and the government's success stories

| By and Nazrul Islam
Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was assassinated through conspiracies by plotters from both home and abroad during 1975. Following the tragic death of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, Bangladesh was ruled
Good governance and the government's success stories

Technology and the youths

| By and Dr. Asaduzzaman Chowdhury
Who will take Bangladesh towards the vision of a developed country? Who will carry the creative ideas forward? Who will change the traditional society? By whom, with the power
Technology and the youths

For better healthcare services in Bangladesh

| By and Mazadul Hoque
During our school life, we frequently faced two translations in tests including school and board level exams -- the patient had died before the doctor came, and the patient

CPD's conflated myths and the country's advancement

| By and Maloy Mondal
Very recently on 13th of January, the Center for Policy Dialogue (CDP) published their State of the Bangladesh Economy in FY2017-18 report where they expressed their strong concerns about
CPD's conflated myths and the country's advancement

What it takes for a Kashmiri Muslim woman to be a political activist in Modi's India

| By and Betwa Sharma
Earlier this month, Shehla Rashid's voice rose with the fervor of a preacher as she railed against the Modi government at a rally organized in the national capital by
What it takes for a Kashmiri Muslim woman to be a political activist in Modi's India

The future direction of Nepal

| By and Dr. N C Bhowmik
Nepal, a nation state having almost same area of Bangladesh, is linked to the history, tradition and culture of five thousand year civilization of the subcontinent and becomes known
The future direction of Nepal

America aggravating crisis in Palestine

| By and Ilan Goldenberg
United States Vice-President Mike Pence is on a trip to Egypt, Jordan and Israel, to support the efforts of the administration of US President Donald Trump in pursuing an
America aggravating crisis in Palestine

Brain and body of a marathon man

| By and Tapan Chakrabarty
Back home, I iced the elbow, then sore from the morning fall. Happy that I assessed the after-fall situation right and did not give up on running that day

Brain and body of a marathon man

| By and Tapan Chakrabarty
14 January, 2018, is a day on which I could have been in the emergency room of a Calgary hospital. I was to go for a 30-km training
Brain and body of a marathon man

Letter from Kolkata

| By and Sujayendra Das
Culture of Indian Judiciary is of terribly complex since long time back. India being a vast nation with 29 states and union territories along with a massive population
Letter from Kolkata

© 2018 The Asian Age